Together We Go Further: LLMs and IDE Static Analysis for Extract Method Refactoring

Replication Package for Paper Submission

GitHub repository

## Table of Contents - **[EM-Assist IntelliJ IDEA Plugin](#plugin)** - **[Datasets](#datasets)** - **[Developer Survey](#survey)**

EM-Assist IntelliJ IDEA Plugin

The IntelliJ IDEA plugin, which offers recommendations for Extract Method refactoring based on the LLM's suggestions, **is [available for free](https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/23403-llm-powered-extract-method) on JetBrains Marketplace**.

EM-Assist Tool Demo: Extract Method refactoring recommendation in IDE.

### Requirements 1. You need to install [IntelliJ IDEA](https://www.jetbrains.com/idea/download) 2023.1 or higher. 2. Configure OpenAI key. ### OpenAI key configuration 1. Sign up for OpenAI at https://beta.openai.com/signup. 2. Get your OpenAI API key. 3. Open IntelliJ IDEA, go to `Settings | Tools | Large Language Models` and enter your API key in the `OpenAI Key`field. ### Plugin installation [Install the EM-Assist plugin](https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/23403-llm-powered-extract-method) from JetBrains Marketplace. ### Usage To use the plugin, you need to right-click on the method, select `Show Context Actions` and click on `Extract Function experiment`. The plugin will then send a request to OpenAI and await a response. Once received, it will present the suggestions in a dialog box, the corresponding code for extraction will be highlighted. To choose one of the suggestions, just right-click on it, and the plugin will automatically apply extract function refactoring.

Datasets

**Comprehensive data is accessible via the provided [link](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/tree/main/datasets)**. To validate our technique, we used the following datasets: 1. _Community Corpus-A_ consists of **122** Java methods and their corresponding Extract Method refactorings collected from five open-source repositories: MyWebMart, SelfPlanner, WikiDev, JHotDraw, and JUnit. This dataset previously served as the foundation for evaluating various state-of-the-art Extract Method refactoring automation tools, including JExtract, JDeodorant, SEMI, GEMS, and REMS. 2. _Community Corpus-B_ Silva et al. maintain an active corpus containing 448 Java methods, each accompanied by its respective extract method refactorings that open-source developers actually performed.Automatable changes represent “clean” commits in which the developers made a single type of change, i.e., performed Extract Method refactoring. We chose the latter category as our focus is on replicating the exact development scenarios where our tool only performs refactorings, it does not expand the code functionality. This resulted in **154** replicable refactorings. 3. _Extended Corpus_: To enhance the robustness of our evaluation with a sizable oracle of actual refactorings performed by developers, we constructed Extended Corpus. To create it, we employed RefactoringMiner for detecting _Extract Method_. We ran it on highly regarded open-source repositories: IntelliJ Community Edition, and CoreNLP. After filtering to remove refactoring commits that mixed feature additions (the one-liners and the extracted methods whose body overlapped a large proportion of the host method), we retain **2,849** _Extract Methods_ from these repositories. Datasets details are available via the **following [link](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/tree/main#dataset-details)**.

Developer Survey

Our tool is a code renovation tool that developers use interactively, it is important to evaluate whether our tool makes suggestions that developers accept. We employ firehouse surveys with professional developers from our collaborating enterprises, focusing on newly created long methods they committed into code repositories. Then, we report their responses regarding the refactoring recommendations proposed by our tool. The table below summarizes the results meant to answer **RQ4. How useful are the provided recommendations to developers?** | User | Method | Screenshot | Strongly
Agree | Agree | Somewhat
Agree | Somewhat
Disagree | Disagree | Strongly
Disagree | |:-----|:----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:------------------:|:-----:|:------------------:|:---------------------:|:--------:|:---------------------:| | P1 | [doGetSeverity()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/2c9c987ef6749e8b9ccab3f1562fba3aff605cde/platform/analysis-impl/src/com/intellij/codeInspection/DefaultInspectionToolResultExporter.java#L311-L332) | [screenshot_p1](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64f906ca0164c6586f8819c8_1.png) | | X | | | | | | P2 | [buildExternalProjectHierarchy()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/b447fdab8cd0c87e6d48ffc11b062992fff99f07/plugins/gradle/tooling-extension-impl/src/com/intellij/gradle/toolingExtension/impl/modelProvider/GradleExternalProjectModelProvider.java#L53-L78) | [screenshot_p2](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64f21f6627a544013cde9c57_1.png) | | | | | | X | | P3 | [fillQualifierAsArgumentContributor()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/e606e6f1e3c129757447719d198432ea78349091/java/java-impl/src/com/intellij/codeInsight/completion/JavaQualifierAsArgumentContributor.java#L50-L76) | [screenshot_p3](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64f9e7d9a7fab75702a0f751_1.png) | | X | | | | | | P4 | [createDependencyDataNode()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/a37fd0a06377d42b59adff93878d1d95bba03659/plugins/gradle/src/org/jetbrains/plugins/gradle/service/project/GradleProjectResolverUtil.java#L744-L776) | [screenshot_p4](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64f9e7d9a7fab75702a0f76a_1.png) | | X | | | | | | P5 | [findMethodToRun()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/9a04255f75b17e689b5fe5928f03d6365e632dff/java/java-runtime/src/com/intellij/rt/execution/application/AppMainV2.java#L160-L191) | [screenshot_p5](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64ff9b2f246a4c7ce85e5d59_1.png) | | | X | | | | | P6 | [loadPluginModules()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/fe6567a53b41c882ccdff76a4f308d694889b78a/platform/runtime/repository/src/com/intellij/platform/runtime/repository/serialization/impl/PluginXmlReader.java#L19-L67) | [screenshot_p6](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64ff9b2f246a4c7ce85e5d57_1.png) | | | | | X | | | P7 | [showInlayRunToCursor()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/48cec9a6137c245b2a18e33e06f5018b83bd92d3/platform/xdebugger-impl/src/com/intellij/xdebugger/impl/XDebuggerManagerImpl.java#L533-L615) | [screenshot_p7](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64ff9b2f246a4c7ce85e5d6d_1.png) | | | X | | | | | P8 | [doGetIllegalDependencies()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/3220db7ada68d2dc878eaeac79119df1d13b43c7/platform/analysis-impl/src/com/intellij/packageDependencies/DependenciesBuilder.java#L94-L119) | [screenshot_p8](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64ff9b2f246a4c7ce85e5d70_1.png) | | | | | | X | | P9 | [stripTextBlockIndent()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/358ad307c273983bef197efed57d4812b51c8b0a/java/java-psi-impl/src/com/intellij/psi/impl/source/tree/java/PsiFragmentImpl.java#L96-L128) | [screenshot_p9](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/64ff9b2f246a4c7ce85e5d78_2.png) | | X | | | | | | P10 | [checkLibraries()](https://github.com/JetBrains/JetBrainsRuntime/blob/7e8a41055c93578d5d7afb6d1fe44177bd927c06/src/java.desktop/share/classes/sun/font/FontManagerNativeLibrary.java#L84-L134) | [screenshot_p10](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/65021a87c5acc040810d667d_1_selection.png) | | X | | | | | | P11 | [step()](https://github.com/JetBrains/JetBrainsRuntime/blob/01c2d0f6c90e9a41c4daaecb85c577f97be47d59/src/java.base/share/classes/com/jetbrains/internal/ProxyDependencyManager.java#L86-L115) | [screenshot_p11](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/65021a87c5acc040810d66bb_3_selection.png) | X | | | | | | | P12 | [checkXInput()](https://github.com/JetBrains/JetBrainsRuntime/blob/037536c5ebd758dd63331683fc9c07e72548e460/src/java.desktop/unix/classes/sun/awt/X11/XToolkit.java#L2432-L2464) | [screenshot_p12](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/65021a87c5acc040810d66e3_2_selection.png) | X | | | | | | | P13 | [collectAnnotations()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/e19b3396e9e5eddd10009ee4758fd37afe7b397e/java/java-psi-impl/src/com/intellij/psi/impl/cache/TypeInfo.java#L418-L460) | [screenshot_p13](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/intellij-community-collectAnnotations-extraction-suggestion-2.png) | | | X | | | | | P14 | [writeJvmClass()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/a84474dd9e8a5b1b1a4fabe2b2211bf28430026d/jps/jps-builders/src/org/jetbrains/jps/dependency/impl/serializer/SerializerUtil.java#L63-L106) | [screenshot_p14](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/intellij-community-readJvmClass-extraction-suggestion-1.png) | | | X | | | | | P15 | [detectLombokJarsSlow()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/2bfb37c6886c5a8e4ac5edb2038b647f05f74d6f/plugins/lombok/src/main/java/de/plushnikov/intellij/plugin/util/LombokLibraryUtil.java#L42-L75) | [screenshot_p15](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/detectLombokJarsSlow-extraction-suggestion-1.png) | | | X | | | | | P16 | [getProcessOutput()](https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community/blob/02e863680e945c4d514cc6aa7142507e00c7b190/python/python-sdk/src/com/jetbrains/python/sdk/PySdkUtil.java#L119-L171) | [screenshot_p16](https://github.com/llm-refactoring/llm-refactoring-plugin/blob/main/datasets/survey_screenshots/getProcessOutput-extraction-suggestion-3.png) | | X | | | | |